CGMP

24/12/2024 8 min read

Cosmetic batch records (BMR): content, recording and retention

When a batch of cream draws a complaint months later, the batch record is where the factory finds out how that batch was weighed, mixed, filled and tested. A record with missing entries or improperly corrected errors makes that answer unreliable.

Cosmetic batch records (BMR): content, recording and retention
Compounding area with an emulsifying tank, where the batch record is filled in during manufacturing

A cosmetic batch manufacturing record — called the Batch Manufacturing Record (BMR) in ASEAN Appendix VI — is the record of what actually happened to a batch: which raw materials and raw material lots were used, who weighed them, which equipment was used, what the parameters were, what was checked, whether anything abnormal occurred, and who authorized release.

1. What a batch record is and what requires it

Appendix VI of the ASEAN Cosmetic Directive (CGMP-ASEAN) requires that the documentation system "should include the complete history of each batch, from starting materials to finished products" (section 8.1) and that "Batch Manufacturing Records should be prepared for each batch of product." (section 8.3.2).

In Vietnam, the relevant legal bases include:

  • Decree 93/2016/ND-CP (in Vietnamese) on cosmetic manufacturing conditions, Article 15, Clause 4: manufacturers must apply a quality management system in line with CGMP-ASEAN — which includes section 8 on documentation and batch records.
  • Decree 93/2016/ND-CP, Article 4, Clause 3, point d: "Have a manufacturing procedure for each product;". Point e of the same clause ("Have a system for keeping documents and records.") was repealed by Article 12, Clause 1, point b of Decree 155/2018/ND-CP (in Vietnamese), which amends investment and business conditions under the Ministry of Health; Butter-C's reading: the documentation requirement remains part of the obligation to apply CGMP-ASEAN.
  • Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT (in Vietnamese) on cosmetic product management, Article 2, Clause 14: "A cosmetic batch number is a designation in numbers or letters, or a combination of numbers and letters, used to identify a product batch and to allow the entire history of a product batch to be traced, including all stages of the manufacturing process, quality control and distribution of that batch."
  • Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT, Appendix 07-MP (in Vietnamese): Part 1 of the PIF contains the "Batch number/product code system"; Part 3 states "Further detailed information on the manufacturing process, quality management and related manufacturing records, which should be kept ready as required by the regulatory authority."

2. Master formula and batch record: two different documents

The master formula "should be available upon request" and includes (section 8.3.1): product name and code; intended packaging materials and storage conditions; list of raw materials; list of equipment used; in-process controls with limits at the processing and packaging stages, where applicable.

The batch record captures the actual data of one batch. By common practice, the master formula is amended only through change control (in Vietnamese), and batch records are issued as controlled copies bearing the batch number and copy number. In contract manufacturing, note Article 2, Clause 5 of Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT: "The owner of a cosmetic product is the organization or individual that owns the formula, the manufacturing process and the quality specifications of the product." Rights to the master formula and the right to view batch records should be stated clearly in the contract.

3. Minimum content of a batch record

Section 8.3.2 of Appendix VI lists 12 items that each batch record should contain:

Item (section 8.3.2)Suggested entries in practice
i. Name of productProduct name, product code, formula version
ii. Batch formulaRaw material quantities for the batch size; lot numbers of the raw materials actually used
iii. Brief manufacturing processSteps in sequence, parameters and permitted ranges
iv. Batch or code numberBatch number on every page
v. Date of the start and finish of processing and packagingDate (and time, if needed)
vi. Identity of individual major equipment and lines or location usedCodes of tanks, homogenizers, filling machines, rooms
vii. Records of cleaning of equipment used for processing as appropriateReference to cleaning records, clean-status labels
viii. In-process control and laboratory results, such as pH and temperature test recordsMeasured results, limits, person who measured
ix. Packaging line clearance inspection recordsLine clearance record signed by two people
x. Any sampling performed during various steps of processingTime, location, sample quantity
xi. Any investigation of specific failure or discrepanciesDeviation code, investigation results
xii. Results of examinations on packed and labelled productsCheck of batch number, expiry date, weight, appearance

The US FDA draft guidance (2013, non-binding, for reference only) additionally recommends: comparing theoretical and actual yield; and having the selection, weighing and measuring of raw materials and the determination of yield checked by a second person. Appendix VI requires surplus labels and packaging materials to be returned to the store and recorded (section 6.7.4), so packaging records usually include a section reconciling label quantities.

4. Recording and correction rules

Appendix VI's rule for corrections: "If an error is made or detected on a document, it should be corrected in such a manner that the original entry is not lost and correction is made close to the original entry, initialled and dated." (section 8.1.2). For weighing: "All weighing and measurement carried out should be recorded and, where applicable, counterchecked." (section 6.3.2).

Practical checklist for the people who fill in records:

  • Record at the time of the activity, not in advance and not in a catch-up batch afterwards — the FDA (2013) recommends that records be made "in a timely manner after an event occurs".
  • Indelible ink; no pencil, no correction pen.
  • Correct with a single line through the entry so the old figure remains legible, write the correct figure alongside, initial it, and add the date and reason.
  • Fields that do not apply are struck through and marked "not applicable".
  • Whoever performs a step signs for it; the checker reviews the data personally before signing.
  • Results outside the permitted range must be reported immediately and a deviation opened; figures must never be "adjusted" by the person recording.

The pharmaceutical industry's ALCOA+ data integrity concept (Attributable, Legible, Contemporaneous, Original, Accurate, plus Complete, Consistent, Enduring, Available) can be used as a reference; it is not a requirement of the cosmetics regulations.

5. Batch numbers and traceability

Section 6.2 of Appendix VI requires each finished product to carry an identification number that allows the product's history to be traced; "a particular batch number should not be repeated for the same product in order to avoid confusion" (6.2.2); where possible, the batch number is printed on both the immediate and the outer packaging. The batch record links raw material lot numbers to finished product batch numbers, allowing forward and backward tracing — see the article retained samples and batch traceability (in Vietnamese).

6. Batch record review before release

Appendix VI places "review of batch documentation" within the scope of quality control (section 7.1.2) and requires that "All finished products should be approved by Quality Control prior to release." (section 6.8.1). The release decision belongs to the quality unit — see the article QA and QC in a cosmetics factory (in Vietnamese).

Review checklist (practice):

  • All pages and signatures present, no blank fields; every raw material lot had been accepted at weighing; parameters and in-process controls within limits.
  • All deviations recorded, investigated and assessed for their impact on the batch.
  • Yield within the acceptance range; labels and printed packaging reconciled; line clearance record present.
  • Finished product test results meet specifications; retained samples taken.

7. Retention of batch records

Neither Appendix VI nor Decree 93/2016/ND-CP sets a number of years for keeping batch records; the closest legal reference point is Article 48, Clause 4 of Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT: the organization placing the product on the market "must keep the Product Information File (PIF) for at least 3 years from the date the last batch was placed on the market". Because manufacturing records must be "kept ready" under Appendix 07-MP, a reasonable common practice is to keep batch records at least until the batch's expiry date and for no less than the PIF retention obligation; the specific period is stated in the SOP and the contract manufacturing agreement.

8. SOP framework for batch record entries

SOP sectionSuggested content
Purpose, scopeRecord in full the history of each batch manufactured and packaged at the factory
DefinitionsPer sections 8.3 and 14 of Appendix VI and Article 2 of Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT
ResponsibilitiesThe operator records; the checker verifies weighing and measuring; the production manager confirms; the quality unit reviews and authorizes release
ContentIssuing controlled copies; recording and corrections (section 4); recording deviations; review and release (section 6)
RetentionStorage location, retention period, retrieval, destruction at the end of the period
FormsProcessing records, packaging records, weighing slips, cleaning records, line clearance records
TrainingTraining for those who record and those who review; effectiveness assessment (Appendix VI, section 2.2.3)

At Butter-C, every batch manufactured for a client has a batch record and retained samples, and is tested at a GLP / ISO 17025-accredited laboratory before handover, in line with step 8 of the contract manufacturing process.

Frequently asked questions

Are electronic batch records acceptable?

Appendix VI does not prescribe a format; the US FDA draft guidance (2013) states that records may be kept on paper or electronically. For electronic records, common practice is to have access rights, an audit trail of edits, and backups.

How is a wrongly recorded figure corrected?

Per section 8.1.2 of Appendix VI: keep the original entry legible, write the correct figure right next to it, initial and date it; by common practice the reason is also recorded.

Can the brand owner view the batch records of a contract-manufactured product?

This should be agreed in a written contract in accordance with section 11 of Appendix VI; see also the article contract manufacturing of cosmetics and GMP (in Vietnamese).

References

  1. ASEAN Cosmetic Directive (ACD), Appendix VI — ASEAN Guidelines for Cosmetic Good Manufacturing Practice. ASEAN Cosmetic Committee. PDF.
  2. Chính phủ. Nghị định 93/2016/NĐ-CP ngày 01/07/2016 quy định về điều kiện sản xuất mỹ phẩm. [Government of Vietnam. Decree 93/2016/ND-CP of 1 July 2016 on cosmetic manufacturing conditions.]
  3. Chính phủ. Nghị định 155/2018/NĐ-CP ngày 12/11/2018 sửa đổi, bổ sung một số quy định liên quan đến điều kiện đầu tư kinh doanh thuộc phạm vi quản lý nhà nước của Bộ Y tế. [Government of Vietnam. Decree 155/2018/ND-CP of 12 November 2018 amending and supplementing certain regulations on investment and business conditions within the state management scope of the Ministry of Health.]
  4. Bộ Y tế. Thông tư 06/2011/TT-BYT ngày 25/01/2011 quy định về quản lý mỹ phẩm. [Ministry of Health. Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT of 25 January 2011 on cosmetic product management.]
  5. U.S. FDA (2013). Draft Guidance for Industry: Cosmetic Good Manufacturing Practices. Guidance page.

Get started

Talk to us about the product you plan to launch

Please send us your product direction and expected quantities. Our team will get back to you during business hours.

Công ty cổ phần Dược mỹ phẩm Butter-C · Business registration no. 0108681386 (Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment, 03/04/2019)
Head office: Huu Le village, Dai Thanh commune, Hanoi · Factory: Thanh Oai Industrial Cluster, Binh Minh commune, Hanoi, Vietnam
Hotline 0967 176 511 · [email protected] · privacy policy
Product catalog →