CGMP

24/12/2024 8 min read

Cosmetic raw material and packaging supplier evaluation under GMP

Once a non-conforming raw material has gone into the tank, finished product testing can hardly save the batch. Supplier evaluation is the first checkpoint, placed even before the first raw material lot is received into the warehouse.

Cosmetic raw material and packaging supplier evaluation under GMP
Preparing test samples in the laboratory, one step in evaluating raw materials from a new source

A bottle of serum may contain more than a dozen raw materials and several types of packaging from many sources. Supplier evaluation for cosmetic raw materials and packaging is the activity of selecting, approving and monitoring these sources, so that the factory buys only from those that have demonstrated the ability to deliver to specification, with complete documentation and traceable origin.

This article keeps the requirements of the law, the requirements of GMP guidelines and industry common practice clearly separate.

1. Basis: what the law and GMP guidelines say

The Vietnamese cosmetic legislation reviewed does not prescribe a separate "supplier evaluation" procedure; instead it sets requirements on outcomes — raw materials that meet specifications, raw material documentation included in the PIF; GMP guidelines require traceability of origin:

Document, provisionVerbatim text or content
Decree 93/2016/ND-CP (in Vietnamese) on cosmetic manufacturing conditions, Article 4, Clause 3, point a (as amended by Article 13 of Decree 155/2018/ND-CP on investment and business conditions under the Ministry of Health)"Raw materials, auxiliary materials and semi-finished products used in cosmetic manufacturing must meet the manufacturer's quality specifications."
Decree 90/2026/ND-CP (in Vietnamese) on administrative penalties in the health sector, Article 69, Clause 1A fine of VND 30,000,000 to VND 40,000,000 (the level for individuals; double for organizations under Article 4, Clause 5) for violations including "Using raw materials that have expired or do not meet quality specifications in cosmetic manufacturing;" (point c) and manufacturing cosmetics containing prohibited substances or exceeding permitted limits (point g)
Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT on cosmetic product management, Appendix 07-MP (in Vietnamese), Part 2 of the PIF"Quality specifications and test methods of the raw materials. For fragrance ingredients, state the fragrance name and code number, the supplier's name and address, and a commitment of compliance with the guidelines of the International Fragrance Association (IFRA)."; together with raw material safety data "based on information from the supplier"
Appendix VI of the ASEAN Cosmetic Directive (CGMP-ASEAN), section 6.1.2"All deliveries of raw materials and packaging materials should be checked and verified for their conformity to specifications and be traceable to the product."
ASEAN Appendix VI, section 9"Such internal audits may also be extended to suppliers and contractors, if necessary."

The US FDA draft guidance on cosmetic GMP (2013, non-binding) recommends reviewing raw material records including "origin, receipt, examination, testing, disposition, and use records". Many factories use the ISO 9001:2015 framework (requirements for quality management systems) when building their supplier control procedure (common practice). Supplier evaluation is therefore a common-practice tool for demonstrating systematically that raw materials meet the mandatory requirements above.

2. Which suppliers need evaluation, and to what level

A common approach is to group suppliers by their impact on product quality and safety; the table below is an example, and each factory defines its own groups in its SOP:

GroupExamplesSuggested evaluation level
Raw materials with use restrictions or key functionsPreservatives, UV filters, colorants, fragrances, active ingredientsFull documentation, test samples, detailed questionnaire; on-site audit when there is a reason
Common raw materialsOils, thickeners, emulsifiersDocumentation and test samples
Primary (direct-contact) packagingBottles, jars, tubes, caps, pumpsMaterial documentation, compatibility test samples
Printed packaging, labelsCartons, labels, leafletsControl of print artwork and approved samples
Contracted servicesExternal testing laboratories, outsourcing of a single process stepWritten contract (Appendix VI, section 11), capability assessment

Packaging control is covered separately in the article cosmetic packaging control (in Vietnamese).

3. Documents to request from suppliers

Practical checklist for a new raw material:

  • Origin: name and address of the original manufacturer, even when buying through a distributor.
  • Certificate of analysis (CoA) for each lot, technical data sheet (TDS), safety data sheet (SDS).
  • Quality specifications, test methods and safety data — the content the PIF requires under Appendix 07-MP, Part 2.
  • Impurity information for at-risk groups; Appendix 08-MP of Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT (ASEAN guidelines on post-market surveillance) flags points to note when checking the PIF, for example "The presence of Benzene in Carbomers." and "Dioxane content in ethoxylated raw materials, e.g. SLES."
  • Fragrances: name and code number, supplier's name and address, commitment of compliance with IFRA guidelines (Appendix 07-MP).
  • Composition of raw materials supplied as mixtures, for checking against prohibited and restricted substances: Article 13 of Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT requires that "The ingredients of a cosmetic formula must comply with the Annexes – latest version of the ASEAN Cosmetic Agreement".
  • Storage conditions, shelf life or retest date set by the raw material manufacturer.
  • Commitment to notify changes in manufacturing site, process or input sources (common practice, usually written into a quality agreement).

For packaging, specifications should include the name, description, test parameters and acceptance limits, and technical drawings where needed (Appendix VI, section 8.2.1).

4. Steps for approving a new supplier

  1. Proposal: purchasing or R&D states the raw material and the reason for choosing a new source.
  2. Document collection as in section 3; QA checks completeness and consistency (for example, that the lot number on the CoA matches the sample sent).
  3. Document evaluation: compare against the factory's raw material specification, check for prohibited and restricted substances, and define the incoming test parameters.
  4. Sample testing: test against the specification; when replacing a source already in use, R&D prepares comparison samples for sensory profile, viscosity and stability.
  5. System evaluation by questionnaire, or on site for high-risk groups (section 5).
  6. Decision: approved, conditionally approved (for example, tightened testing of the first few lots) or not approved.
  7. Update the approved supplier list: raw material, original manufacturer, scope and approval status.

If the new source replaces one already used in a notified product, the change should go through change control (in Vietnamese), because the PIF may need to be updated and stability monitored.

5. On-site and questionnaire-based evaluation

Appendix VI allows self-inspection to be extended to suppliers "if necessary" and requires that "A report should be made at the completion of each internal audit." Common practice is to use questionnaires for most suppliers and to audit on site only when the raw material is high risk, there is a history of failed lots, or the questionnaire leaves points unclear. Areas typically reviewed:

  • Quality system: written procedures, document control, handling of deviations and complaints.
  • Control of input sources, batch numbering system and traceability.
  • Testing capability for issuing CoAs (if outsourced, which laboratory).
  • Storage and transport; for distributors, how materials are repacked and relabeled.

Each finding should be graded, assigned a corrective action with a deadline, and documented.

6. Monitoring and periodic re-evaluation

Commonly used monitoring indicators (common practice):

  • Number of lots rejected or held in prolonged quarantine at incoming inspection.
  • Discrepancies between the CoA and the factory's periodic verification test results.
  • Deviations and complaints caused by raw materials or packaging (see the article deviations and CAPA in cosmetics (in Vietnamese)).
  • Deliveries on time, under the right conditions and with complete documents; change notifications as committed.

The re-evaluation cycle is set by the factory's SOP according to risk level; neither the law nor Appendix VI sets a figure. A supplier whose results deteriorate may be moved to conditional approval, suspended or removed.

7. When the product is contract-manufactured

In contract manufacturing, suppliers may be chosen by the factory or designated by the brand owner. Appendix VI, section 11, requires a written contract "to clearly establish the duties and responsibilities of each party"; the contract should state who evaluates suppliers, who keeps the records, and who is responsible when a raw material designated by the client fails. The PIF is kept at the address of the organization placing the product on the market (Article 11 of Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT), so supplier documents need to be handed over in full. See also the article contract manufacturing of cosmetics and GMP (in Vietnamese).

If you designate raw materials or packaging from your own sources, it is advisable to prepare the documents listed in section 3 before production; Butter-C prepares the PIF and notification dossier for clients and will place these documents in the correct parts of the PIF.

Frequently asked questions

Does every supplier need an on-site audit?

No. Appendix VI only states that self-inspection may be extended to suppliers "if necessary"; common practice is to select by risk level.

When raw materials are bought through a distributor, who is evaluated?

Both: know the original manufacturer and the original CoA, and also evaluate how the distributor stores, repacks and relabels.

If the CoA shows a pass, is incoming testing still needed?

Section 6.1.2 of Appendix VI requires raw material samples to be checked before release for use. Reducing test parameters on the basis of the CoA is common practice when the supplier has been approved and periodic verification testing is in place — see the article raw material quality management.

References

  1. ASEAN Cosmetic Directive (ACD), Appendix VI — ASEAN Guidelines for Cosmetic Good Manufacturing Practice. ASEAN Cosmetic Committee. PDF.
  2. Chính phủ. Nghị định 93/2016/NĐ-CP ngày 01/07/2016 quy định về điều kiện sản xuất mỹ phẩm. [Government of Vietnam. Decree 93/2016/ND-CP of 1 July 2016 on cosmetic manufacturing conditions.]
  3. Bộ Y tế. Thông tư 06/2011/TT-BYT ngày 25/01/2011 quy định về quản lý mỹ phẩm. [Ministry of Health. Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT of 25 January 2011 on cosmetic product management.]
  4. Chính phủ. Nghị định 90/2026/NĐ-CP ngày 30/03/2026 quy định xử phạt vi phạm hành chính trong lĩnh vực y tế. [Government of Vietnam. Decree 90/2026/ND-CP of 30 March 2026 on penalties for administrative violations in the health sector.]
  5. U.S. FDA (2013). Draft Guidance for Industry: Cosmetic Good Manufacturing Practices. Guidance page.
  6. ISO 9001:2015. Quality management systems — Requirements.

Get started

Talk to us about the product you plan to launch

Please send us your product direction and expected quantities. Our team will get back to you during business hours.

Công ty cổ phần Dược mỹ phẩm Butter-C · Business registration no. 0108681386 (Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment, 03/04/2019)
Head office: Huu Le village, Dai Thanh commune, Hanoi · Factory: Thanh Oai Industrial Cluster, Binh Minh commune, Hanoi, Vietnam
Hotline 0967 176 511 · [email protected] · privacy policy
Product catalog →