Cosmetic ingredients

18/11/2026 10 min read

Stannous fluoride (tin fluoride) in oral care cosmetics

Stannous fluoride is a fluoride source with an added tin(II) component: it has been studied extensively in dentistry but is hard to keep stable and can cause staining. This article separates research data from cosmetic claim wording, with concentration conversion, notes on tin allergy and the points a manufacturer must check.

Stannous fluoride (tin fluoride) in oral care cosmetics
A bamboo toothbrush resting on the edge of a white bathroom sink — stannous fluoride is a fluoride source in toothpaste, with its own limits and warnings under ASEAN Annex III

Stannous fluoride (INCI: Stannous Fluoride; Vietnamese name: thiếc(II) fluorid, i.e. tin(II) fluoride, SnF2) is a compound of tin and fluorine, used as a fluoride source in toothpaste, tooth gel and mouthwash. In ASEAN countries, it may be used only in oral hygiene products, at a maximum of 0.15% calculated as fluorine, and a warning must be printed on the label.

Compared with sodium fluoride, stannous fluoride also carries a tin(II) component: this part oxidizes easily, which makes the formula harder to stabilize, and it can cause staining on teeth. General information on fluoride, children and concentration conversion is in the article sodium fluoride in cosmetics (in Vietnamese).

1. What is stannous fluoride?

According to PubChem (CID 24550), stannous fluoride has the formula SnF2, a molecular weight of 156.71 g/mol and CAS number 7783-47-3. PubChem describes it as a white crystalline powder, soluble at about 30–39% in water at 20 °C and practically insoluble in ethanol.

From the atomic masses it follows that 1 g of SnF2 contains about 0.2425 g of fluorine (2 × 18.998 / 156.71), much lower than sodium fluoride (about 45.2%).

2. Why is stannous fluoride hard to keep stable?

  • It does not simply split into ions: according to a review by Nicholson (2025; the author has ties to a biomaterials company), in water SnF2 exists mainly in undissociated form and as SnF+; over time, the fluorine is gradually replaced by hydroxide groups.
  • Hydrolysis and oxidation: HSDB data on PubChem state that aqueous solutions of stannous fluoride decompose within a few hours to tin hydroxides, forming a white precipitate. According to Nicholson (2025), dissolved oxygen oxidizes tin(II) to tin(IV); the resulting SnO2 is abrasive, roughening the surface and making it prone to picking up stain. The way to limit this is to reduce water and add stabilizers.
  • Excipients are decisive: Myers et al. (2019) analyzed many commercial toothpastes by X-ray spectroscopy (XANES) and found that the degree of SnF2 oxidation varied widely, determined by the excipients; in this study, zinc phosphate kept the tin more stable than other approaches. The study was funded by a toothpaste manufacturer.
  • After the tube is opened: a study summarized by Nicholson (2025) found that the tin was partly oxidized during packaging and storage, and further after the tube was opened many times.

3. Evidence: dental data, not claim wording

The results below were measured on complete toothpaste formulas containing stannous fluoride, usually together with stabilizers. The results belong to the whole formula and are not a promise for a new product.

SourceDesign, sizeMain results (per abstract)
Gormley et al., 2026Network meta-analysis: 93 randomized trials (9,548 adults with dentin hypersensitivity); 47 trials (4,636 people) included in the meta-analysisAfter 2 weeks, compared with standard fluoride toothpaste, stannous fluoride toothpaste reduced sensitivity to a cold air blast (MD −0.85; 95% CI −1.08 to −0.62; high certainty) and to tactile stimulation (MD 14.87; 95% CI 10.24–19.50; moderate certainty)
Konradsson et al., 2020Systematic review: 3 caries studies, 8 dental erosion studies, 11 sensitivity studiesCaries: results similar to or slightly better than non-stannous fluoride toothpaste; acid erosion: better in 7/8 studies; a meta-analysis of 6 8-week sensitivity studies favored SnF2. High risk of bias in most of the caries and erosion studies
Johannsen et al., 2019Systematic review: 21 plaque and gingivitis studies, 5 staining studiesA meta-analysis of 6-month gingivitis studies favored SnF2, but the trials were highly heterogeneous; staining: no difference found
  • Industry involvement: the full text of Johannsen et al. (2019) notes that many studies were funded by manufacturers or had manufacturer employees as authors. The three reviews in the table have authors from universities and hospitals.
  • Gingivitis and plaque are dental indices scored by dentists. Butter-C does not use these results as product claims.
  • Not fully consistent: Nicholson (2025) cites some sensitivity trials that found no difference compared with control toothpaste, partly because of the placebo effect. Other actives for sensitive teeth: potassium nitrate (in Vietnamese), arginine (in Vietnamese).

Butter-C’s assessment: high to moderate evidence for reducing dentin hypersensitivity in adults (Gormley et al., 2026); evidence on caries is still limited.

4. Concentration and conversion to fluorine

The table below is a calculation using the 0.2425 factor and assumes a completely pure raw material; actual formulas are adjusted according to the certificate of analysis (COA).

SnF2 in the finished productCorresponding fluorine (calculated)Context
0.454%about 0.110% F (about 1,100 ppm)Level used in many of the clinical trials reviewed
up to about 0.61%0.15% F (1,500 ppm)Limit under Annex III of the ASEAN Cosmetic Directive, adding up all fluorine sources; rounded down

If sodium fluoride or sodium monofluorophosphate is also added, the fluorine from all sources counts toward one total of no more than 0.15%.

5. Tooth staining

According to Johannsen et al. (2019), first-generation SnF2 formulas could cause surface staining of teeth; later formulas added sodium hexametaphosphate (a polyphosphate) to overcome this. For mouthwash, in the crossover trial by West et al. (2012), participants stopped brushing and rinsed with the mouthwash and then with black tea every hour, eight times a day, for 4 days: all three test rinses (two containing amine fluoride/stannous fluoride, one essential oil rinse) caused more staining than water, and overall the tin-containing formulas tended to cause more staining. According to the authors, this staining can be removed by professional cleaning at the dentist.

6. Safety: who should take care

  • Contact allergy to tin: Franken et al. (2026) retrospectively analyzed patch testing in Belgium and the Netherlands. Among 1,919 consecutive patients, 128 (6.7%) tested positive to at least one tin preparation, 35 of them clinically relevant; among 536 patients with suspected metal allergy or perioral symptoms, 61 (11.4%) were sensitized. Perioral manifestations were common, and tin-containing toothpaste was a frequently identified source. The authors note that testing with tin chloride may give false-positive results. People who develop cheilitis or a persistent burning sensation in the mouth when using a tin-containing toothpaste should stop using it and consult a dermatologist.
  • Fluoride and children: the 2003 SCCNFP opinion concluded that the maximum level of 0.15% F does not raise safety concerns for children under 6 years of age; the data come mainly from sodium fluoride, so for other fluorine compounds the conclusion can be extrapolated only with regard to dental fluorosis. A child who swallows a large amount of toothpaste should be taken to a medical facility.
  • Raw material: the classification notifications submitted to ECHA (aggregated on PubChem) are not consistent; many state that it is harmful if swallowed, causes skin irritation and causes serious eye damage. Staff weighing the powder need gloves and safety goggles.
  • Pregnancy and breastfeeding: data are insufficient; consult a doctor.

7. Perspective for brand owners (B2B)

  • ASEAN regulations (Annex III, version 2026-1, June 22, 2026), Ref 35: "Tin difluoride / Stannous fluoride", CAS 7783-47-3; scope (a) oral hygiene products other than mouthwash, (b) mouthwash; maximum "0.15 % calculated as F", with total F from all fluorine compounds not exceeding 0.15%. Label for (a) and (b): "Contains stannous fluoride". Label for (a): "Children of 6 years and younger: use a pea-sized amount for supervised brushing to minimise swallowing. In case of intake of fluoride from other sources consult a dentist or doctor." Label for (b): "Do not use for children below 6 years of age". Footnote (12): applies to toothpastes containing 0.1–0.15% fluoride, unless already labeled as contraindicated for children (e.g., "For adult use only"); together with a 6 mm solid circle between the words "pea sized" and "amount".
  • Outside oral care: Annex II, Ref 191 prohibits "Hydrofluoric acid, its normal salts, its complexes and hydrofluorides", except the substances in Annex III, Part 1. Butter-C does not use stannous fluoride outside oral care products.
  • Formulation: a low-water or anhydrous base with a tin(II) stabilizing system, mixing with limited exposure to oxygen, and oxygen- and moisture-barrier packaging. Every stabilizer must pass a regulatory check against Annex III (for example, water-soluble zinc salts are restricted under Ref 24).
  • Testing: assay of total fluorine, soluble fluorine and tin(II) or soluble tin at the time of manufacture, after aging and after the tube has been opened many times; monitor the color of the paste.
  • Claims: Butter-C uses "contains fluoride", "cleans teeth" and "helps freshen breath". For the sensitive-teeth line: "helps reduce the sensation of sensitivity in sensitive teeth with regular daily use", once the regulatory team approves each dossier. The claim "helps prevent cavities" is used only when the regulatory department confirms it in writing. No statements about the gums, oral diseases or bacteria; no figures from other studies on the label.

Butter-C uses stannous fluoride in contract manufacturing of toothpaste for sensitive teeth, with a low-water base, total fluorine calculated according to Annex III, stability studies that include tin parameters, and warning labels reviewed before printing.

Frequently asked questions

How do stannous fluoride and sodium fluoride differ?

Both are fluoride sources in ASEAN Annex III, with the same limit of 0.15% total F. Stannous fluoride oxidizes and hydrolyzes easily in a water-based formula, so it needs a low-water base and a stabilizing system.

Does toothpaste with stannous fluoride stain teeth?

It can, especially with first-generation formulas, and with tin-containing mouthwash in the tea-staining model. Surface stains can be removed at the dentist.

Does stannous fluoride toothpaste help reduce sensitivity?

In a 2026 review in adults, stannous fluoride toothpaste reduced sensitivity after 2 weeks compared with standard fluoride toothpaste. That is the result for the formulas tested. Persistent sensitivity needs a dentist’s examination.

Who should not use tin-containing toothpaste?

People with a known tin allergy, or who develop cheilitis or a persistent burning sensation in the mouth when using a tin-containing toothpaste, should stop using it and consult a doctor. Children aged 6 and under need adult supervision when brushing.

References

  1. Gormley AJ et al. Dentifrice formulations for the treatment of dentin hypersensitivity: A systematic review and network meta-analysis. Periodontol 2000. 2026. PMID 42670780
  2. Konradsson K et al. Stabilized stannous fluoride dentifrice in relation to dental caries, dental erosion and dentin hypersensitivity: A systematic review. Am J Dent. 2020. PMID 32259415
  3. Johannsen A et al. Effects of stabilized stannous fluoride dentifrice on dental calculus, dental plaque, gingivitis, halitosis and stain: A systematic review. Heliyon. 2019. PMID 31872105 · full text: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6909063/
  4. Myers CP et al. Solving the problem with stannous fluoride: Formulation, stabilization, and antimicrobial action. J Am Dent Assoc. 2019. PMID 30797260
  5. Nicholson JW. Stannous Fluoride in Toothpastes: A Review of Its Clinical Effects and Likely Mechanisms of Action. J Funct Biomater. 2025. PMID 40137352
  6. West NX et al. A randomised crossover trial to compare the potential of stannous fluoride and essential oil mouth rinses to induce tooth and tongue staining. Clin Oral Investig. 2012. PMID 21614461
  7. Franken SM et al. Tin Sensitization in Belgium and the Netherlands: Complementary Findings From Two Independent Retrospective Studies. Contact Dermatitis. 2026. PMID 42778194
  8. NCBI PubChem. Stannous fluoride (CID 24550) https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/24550 · SCCNFP. Opinion concerning the safety of fluorine compounds in oral hygiene products for children under the age of 6 years (SCCNFP/0653/03, 2003) https://ec.europa.eu/health/ph_risk/committees/sccp/documents/out219_en.pdf · ASEAN Annex III (2026-1): https://asean.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Annex-III_Release_22nd-June-2026-clean.pdf

Get started

Talk to us about the product you plan to launch

Please send us your product direction and expected quantities. Our team will get back to you during business hours.

Công ty cổ phần Dược mỹ phẩm Butter-C · Business registration no. 0108681386 (Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment, 03/04/2019)
Head office: Huu Le village, Dai Thanh commune, Hanoi · Factory: Thanh Oai Industrial Cluster, Binh Minh commune, Hanoi, Vietnam
Hotline 0967 176 511 · [email protected] · privacy policy
Product catalog →