Cosmetic ingredients

19/11/2026 10 min read

Sodium monofluorophosphate (MFP) in cosmetics: conversion, labels

Sodium monofluorophosphate (MFP) is a familiar fluoride source in calcium carbonate-based toothpaste. This article explains how MFP releases fluoride, the dental data compared with non-fluoride toothpaste and with sodium fluoride, how to convert concentrations, why soluble fluoride must be measured, and the conditions of ASEAN Annex III.

Sodium monofluorophosphate (MFP) in cosmetics: conversion, labels
A teaching model of the teeth (pink gums) next to a row of enlarged molar models on a white shelf — illustrating tooth enamel, where the fluoride ions released from MFP act

Sodium monofluorophosphate (INCI: Sodium Monofluorophosphate; Vietnamese name: natri monofluorophosphat; abbreviated MFP or SMFP) is an inorganic salt, Na2PO3F, used as a fluoride source in toothpaste, especially calcium carbonate-based toothpaste. Unlike in sodium fluoride, the fluorine in MFP is held in the monofluorophosphate ion and becomes free fluoride ion only when this ion is hydrolyzed. In ASEAN countries, MFP may be used only in oral hygiene products, at a maximum of 0.15% calculated as fluorine, with a mandatory warning on the label.

This article covers only the points specific to MFP. General information on fluoride, dental fluorosis and the risk of swallowing large amounts of toothpaste is in the article sodium fluoride in cosmetics (in Vietnamese).

1. What is sodium monofluorophosphate?

According to PubChem (CID 24266), MFP has the formula Na2PO3F and a molecular weight of 143.95 g/mol, and is a white powder; its list of synonyms includes both CAS numbers 10163-15-2 and 7631-97-2, which match entry Ref 27 of ASEAN Annex III. The ASEAN text calls this substance "Disodium fluorophosphate", so the mandatory label statement uses that name.

From the atomic masses it follows that 1 g of MFP contains about 0.132 g of fluorine (18.998 / 143.95), i.e. about 13.2%, compared with about 45.2% for sodium fluoride. To reach the same fluorine level, about 3.4 times as much MFP is needed as sodium fluoride.

2. From MFP to fluoride ion in the mouth

According to Pearce and Dibdin (2003), MFP is broken down by bacterial phosphatase enzymes in plaque into fluoride and orthophosphate. For both natural and artificial plaque, the optimum pH for hydrolysis is about 8; hydrolysis decreases as the pH moves away from this level. MFP in toothpaste extracts is also affected by the toothpaste's own pH, while the other ingredients reduce hydrolysis by no more than 10%. The authors suggest that MFP toothpastes should be formulated to favor enzymatic hydrolysis, and that control of plaque pH is probably the most important factor.

Once it has become fluoride ion, its mechanism on tooth enamel is the same as that of other fluoride sources.

3. Evidence: dental data, not claim wording

The studies below measured caries increment in children. The results belong to the whole toothpaste formula and are not a promise for any specific product.

SourceDesignMain results (per abstract)
Fan et al., 2008Randomized, double-blind, 2 years; 1,200 children in Chengdu (China), 998 completed1.14% MFP toothpastes with a calcium carbonate base and with a silica base significantly reduced caries increment compared with non-fluoride toothpaste (42% and 37% after 2 years); the two bases did not differ significantly
Saporito et al., 2000Randomized, double-blind, multicenter, 2 years; 2,479 children completedA 0.243% sodium fluoride toothpaste with a silica base and a 0.76% MFP toothpaste with a dicalcium phosphate dihydrate base had the same mean caries increment after 2 years (3.56); the authors concluded that they were equivalent under American Dental Association guidelines
Stookey et al., 1993Expert panel review, with a meta-analysis of head-to-head comparisonsSodium fluoride was significantly more effective (p < 0.01), by 5–10% over 2–3 years; sodium fluoride recommended where feasible, provided the abrasive is compatible
Holloway and Worthington, 1993Critique of the papers used in a meta-analysis comparing the two substancesErrors in study selection and data extraction; on re-examination, 3 studies favored MFP, 2 favored sodium fluoride and 5 should not have been included; the two rigorous studies did not show either substance to be better

Reading it at the right level: MFP toothpaste was effective compared with non-fluoride toothpaste in trials in children, while the question of whether MFP or sodium fluoride is better has no consistent answer yet. The 2000 and 2008 trials used commercial toothpastes; PubMed lists only the first author's affiliation (a university), but some co-authors are listed at a toothpaste manufacturer in other papers on PubMed.

4. Concentration and conversion to fluorine

The ASEAN limit is calculated as fluorine, not as the salt. The table below is a calculation using the 0.132 factor and assumes a completely pure raw material; actual formulas are adjusted according to the assay on the certificate of analysis (COA). The limit row is rounded down.

Fluorine in the finished productCorresponding MFP (calculated)Context
1,000 ppm (0.10% F)about 0.76%MFP level of the toothpaste in the Saporito (2000) trial
1,450 ppm (0.145% F)about 1.10%Labeled level of the calcium carbonate-based MFP toothpaste in the Falcão (2013) study
1,500 ppm (0.15% F)up to about 1.13%ASEAN Annex III limit, adding up all fluorine sources

The 1.14% MFP level in the Fan (2008) trial, if the raw material were completely pure, corresponds to about 0.1505% F, slightly above the 0.15% ceiling — do not copy this figure; recalculate from the COA. If sodium fluoride or stannous fluoride is also added, the fluorine from all sources counts toward one total of no more than 0.15%.

5. Abrasives, stability and soluble fluoride

In the in vitro experiment by Hattab (1989), adding sodium fluoride solution to calcium- or aluminum-containing abrasives caused a loss of 60–90% of the added fluorine after one week, whereas calcium-containing abrasives were clearly more compatible with MFP; silica was inert toward the fluorine of both substances. After 12 months, the soluble fluorine of an MFP – calcium carbonate/sodium silicate toothpaste was twice that of an MFP – calcium carbonate/aluminum silicate toothpaste.

"Better compatibility" does not mean stable forever:

  • After one year of storage at about 22 °C, 5/30 toothpastes in Chile had 30–50% insoluble fluorine, 4 of which used MFP with calcium-containing abrasives; in 2 toothpastes, soluble fluorine fell below 1,000 ppm (Fernández et al., 2017).
  • In a blind crossover trial in 20 adults, a calcium carbonate-based MFP toothpaste had about 20% insoluble fluorine when fresh and about 40% after accelerated aging; the bioavailability of swallowed fluoride was lower than with a silica-based sodium fluoride toothpaste. The amount of soluble fluorine swallowed, not total fluorine, correlated with bioavailability (Falcão et al., 2013).

Therefore, for calcium carbonate-based MFP toothpaste, both total fluorine and total soluble fluorine (fluoride ion plus monofluorophosphate ion) need to be measured at release and throughout stability studies in the actual packaging. See also the articles on calcium carbonate (in Vietnamese) and hydrated silica (in Vietnamese).

6. Safety: who should take care

  • Children: toothpaste containing MFP carries the same warning as sodium fluoride toothpaste (a pea-sized amount, supervised brushing); the amount of toothpaste by age is in the article daily oral care routine (in Vietnamese). Falcão and colleagues propose estimating the risk of dental fluorosis from swallowing calcium carbonate-based MFP toothpaste on the basis of soluble fluorine instead of total fluorine.
  • Swallowing a large amount: this is a medical situation and the child needs to be taken to a medical facility; this article does not give management instructions.
  • Irritation, allergy: our PubMed search (November 2026) found no case reports of contact allergy specific to MFP; this does not rule out reactions. People who have reacted to a toothpaste before should consult a dermatologist or dentist.
  • Raw material: according to the aggregated ECHA C&L notifications on PubChem, 91.7% of 72 reports classify MFP as harmful if swallowed (H302), and 11.1% state that it causes skin irritation (H315).
  • Pregnancy and breastfeeding: data are insufficient; consult a doctor.

7. Perspective for brand owners (B2B)

  • ASEAN Annex III (version 2026-1, June 22, 2026), Ref 27 "Disodium fluorophosphate / Sodium monofluorophosphate", CAS 10163-15-2/7631-97-2: scope "(a) Oral hygiene products (except mouthwash) (b) Mouthwash"; limit "0.15% calculated as F. When mixed with other fluorine compounds permitted under this Annex, total F concentration must not exceed 0.15%". Label for (a) and (b): "Contains Disodium fluorophosphate."; label for (a): "Children of 6 years and younger: use a pea-sized amount for supervised brushing to minimize swallowing. In case of intake of fluoride from other sources consult a dentist or doctor."; label for (b): "Do not use for children below 6 years of age". Footnote (12): the children's warning in label (a) applies to all toothpastes containing 0.1–0.15% fluoride, unless the label already states that the product is contraindicated for children (e.g. "For adult use only"); the label must also carry a solid circle 6 mm in diameter between the words "pea sized" and "amount" to indicate the amount to use.
  • Outside oral care: Annex II, Ref 191 prohibits hydrofluoric acid, its normal salts, its complexes and hydrofluorides, except the substances in Annex III, Part 1; Ref 27 covers only oral care, so Butter-C does not use MFP in other products. Annex VI (version 2026-1) and Annex VII (version 2025-2) have no entry for MFP.
  • Pairing fluoride source and abrasive: a calcium carbonate base goes with MFP, not with sodium fluoride; a silica base can use either (Hattab, 1989). If the grade or supplier of the abrasive changes, measure soluble fluorine again.
  • pH: because enzymatic hydrolysis depends on pH, the pH of the finished product needs an acceptance range in the specification and should be monitored during stability testing.
  • Claims: Butter-C uses "contains fluoride", "cleans teeth" and "helps freshen breath"; the claim "helps prevent cavities" is used only when the regulatory department confirms it in writing. Trial data are not presented as the product's efficacy, and no claims are made about gum disease or bacteria.

Butter-C uses sodium monofluorophosphate in contract manufacturing of calcium carbonate-based toothpaste, with total fluorine calculated according to the COA, total and soluble fluorine assayed at manufacture and after aging, and labels per Ref 27 reviewed before printing.

Frequently asked questions

How do MFP and sodium fluoride differ?

Both are permitted under ASEAN Annex III with the same ceiling of 0.15% F. Sodium fluoride provides fluoride ion as soon as it dissolves; MFP needs to be hydrolyzed, mostly by enzymes in plaque. MFP is clearly more compatible with calcium-containing abrasives, so it is chosen for calcium carbonate-based toothpaste.

Is MFP toothpaste less effective than sodium fluoride toothpaste?

There is no consistent answer yet: a 1993 meta-analysis found sodium fluoride 5–10% better but was criticized, while a 2-year trial in 2,479 children found the same caries increment in both groups (section 3).

Why does the label say "Disodium fluorophosphate"?

Because the mandatory label statement in Ref 27 uses exactly this name. The ingredient list still shows the INCI name Sodium Monofluorophosphate; the Vietnamese version of the label statement is confirmed by the regulatory department.

Can MFP be used in skin creams?

No. Under ASEAN Annex III, MFP is permitted only in oral hygiene products and mouthwash.

References

  1. Pearce EI, Dibdin GH. The effect of pH, temperature and plaque thickness on the hydrolysis of monofluorophosphate in experimental dental plaque. Caries Res. 2003. PMID 12740540
  2. Fan X et al. Clinical investigation of the anticaries efficacy of a 1.14% sodium monofluorophosphate (SMFP) calcium carbonate-based dentifrice: a two-year caries clinical trial on children in China. J Clin Dent. 2008. PMID 19278083
  3. Saporito RA et al. Comparative anticaries efficacy of sodium fluoride and sodium monofluorophosphate dentifrices. A two-year caries clinical trial on children in New Jersey and Puerto Rico. Am J Dent. 2000. PMID 11763937
  4. Stookey GK et al. A critical review of the relative anticaries efficacy of sodium fluoride and sodium monofluorophosphate dentifrices. Caries Res. 1993. PMID 8402812
  5. Holloway PJ, Worthington HV. Sodium fluoride or sodium monofluorophosphate? A critical view of a meta-analysis on their relative effectiveness in dentifrices. Am J Dent. 1993. PMID 7488357
  6. Hattab FN. The state of fluorides in toothpastes. J Dent. 1989. PMID 2732364
  7. Fernández CE et al. Stability of chemically available fluoride in Chilean toothpastes. Int J Paediatr Dent. 2017. PMID 28134464
  8. Falcão A et al. Fluoride gastrointestinal absorption from Na2FPO3/CaCO3- and NaF/SiO2-based toothpastes. Caries Res. 2013. PMID 23295625

Get started

Talk to us about the product you plan to launch

Please send us your product direction and expected quantities. Our team will get back to you during business hours.

Công ty cổ phần Dược mỹ phẩm Butter-C · Business registration no. 0108681386 (Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment, 03/04/2019)
Head office: Huu Le village, Dai Thanh commune, Hanoi · Factory: Thanh Oai Industrial Cluster, Binh Minh commune, Hanoi, Vietnam
Hotline 0967 176 511 · [email protected] · privacy policy
Product catalog →