Strontium chloride in toothpaste for sensitive teeth
Strontium chloride is a long-established active in toothpaste for sensitive teeth, but meta-analyses have produced inconsistent results. This article separates the data on strontium chloride from those on strontium acetate, converts the limits to strontium and quotes the exact conditions of ASEAN Annex III.
Strontium chloride (INCI: Strontium Chloride; Vietnamese name: stronti clorid, SrCl2) is an inorganic salt of strontium used in toothpaste for sensitive teeth; the trials of toothpastes containing only strontium chloride that Butter-C has reviewed used a level of 10% in the form with six molecules of water of crystallization (hexahydrate). The evidence is inconsistent: an older placebo-controlled trial gave good results, but several meta-analyses found no clear difference between strontium-containing toothpastes and controls. In ASEAN, strontium chloride is a restricted substance (Annex III, Ref 57), with limits calculated as strontium and two mandatory warning statements.
Other actives for sensitive teeth are covered in the articles on potassium nitrate (in Vietnamese), stannous fluoride and arginine (in Vietnamese).
1. What is strontium chloride?
According to PubChem, the anhydrous form, SrCl2, has a molecular weight of 158.52 g/mol (CID 5362485, CAS 10476-85-4); the hexahydrate, SrCl2·6H2O, is 266.62 g/mol (CID 6101868, CAS 10025-70-4) and, according to PubChem, may lose water or absorb moisture depending on air humidity. Ref 57 gives the name "Strontium chloride hexahydrate" but with CAS 10476-85-4, the CAS number PubChem assigns to the anhydrous form; the certificate of analysis (COA) therefore needs to state the salt form clearly.
From the atomic mass of strontium (87.62) it can be calculated that strontium makes up about 55.3% of the anhydrous form by weight and 32.9% of the hexahydrate. The regulatory limits are calculated as strontium, not as the salt (section 4).
Strontium chloride is different from strontium acetate (Strontium Acetate), a salt with its own entry (Ref 58). Data on strontium acetate toothpastes are not used as evidence for strontium chloride.
2. Mechanism: the dentinal tubule occlusion hypothesis
According to Jang et al. (2023), there are two approaches to reducing dentin hypersensitivity: reducing nerve transmission (the approach of potassium nitrate) and occluding open dentinal tubules. Strontium belongs to the second approach: the authors write that strontium is chemically similar to calcium, binds strongly to mineralized tissue such as dentin and may promote mineralization, leading to occlusion of the dentinal tubules.
- Still a hypothesis: the mechanistic studies on strontium chloride in Butter-C’s scientific dossier are all small or in vitro (outside the body).
- Confounding factor: also according to Jang et al. (2023), silica abrasive particles measure 3.94–20.4 μm while dentinal tubule openings measure 1.0–5.0 μm, so the abrasive particles may themselves plug some tubules; a toothpaste without an active can also reduce sensitivity.
3. Evidence: inconsistent results
| Source | Design, size | Results for strontium | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minkoff & Axelrod, 1987 | Double-blind, placebo-controlled; 61 people; 12 weeks | 10% strontium chloride hexahydrate toothpaste reduced sensitivity significantly more than placebo on all three measures; the difference was seen from week 2 | Abstract does not state the sponsor |
| Jang et al., 2023 | Randomized, double-blind; 53 people (18 in the strontium group); 4 weeks | 10% strontium chloride hexahydrate toothpaste did not differ significantly from toothpaste without an active (air blast p = 0.0901; cold p = 0.4782) | Full text: funded by the manufacturer of the comparison toothpaste (tricalcium phosphate) |
| Liu & Hu, 2012 | Randomized, double-blind, vs. base toothpaste; 81 people; 3 days | 2% strontium chloride + 5% potassium nitrate toothpaste was significantly better than the base toothpaste after the first use and after 3 days | The result belongs to the whole formula; the main sponsor was a university (ClinicalTrials.gov) |
| Bae et al., 2015 | Meta-analysis of 31 randomized trials | Strontium-containing toothpaste: SMD 0.05 (95% CI −0.34 to 0.44), not significant, 4 studies | Abstract does not state the salt |
| Grünberg et al., 2017 | Network meta-analysis; 9 papers, 2006–2015 | Strontium acetate: significant improvement compared with placebo; strontium chloride “equivalent to the placebo” | Analyzes the two salts separately |
| Hu et al., 2018 | Meta-analysis of 53 randomized trials, 4,796 adults | Strontium-containing toothpaste no better than negative control; potassium + strontium toothpaste beneficial; evidence level “low” for both | Abstract does not state the salt |
| Martins et al., 2020 | Network meta-analysis; 125 trials, 12,541 people | Compared with fluoride-only toothpaste, “strontium” was beneficial for tactile stimuli (SMD 1.43; 95% CI 0.46–2.41), moderate certainty | Salts not separated; not among the beneficial groups reported for cold and air-blast stimuli |
- Know which salt was tested: only Grünberg et al. (2017) analyzed strontium chloride separately, and the result was no better than placebo. The other meta-analyses pooled "strontium-containing toothpastes" together.
- Large placebo effect: in Jang et al. (2023), the group using toothpaste without an active showed a 48.52% reduction with air blast and 28.34% with cold stimulus after 4 weeks.
- Compared with other actives: Bae et al. (2015) found that toothpastes containing potassium, stannous fluoride, calcium sodium phosphosilicate or arginine had an effect compared with placebo, whereas strontium-containing toothpastes did not.
Butter-C’s assessment: the evidence for strontium chloride alone is limited and inconsistent. The positive result for a toothpaste containing only strontium chloride comes from the 1987 trial; Martins et al. (2020) pooled the salts together. The meta-analysis that analyzed the salts separately and the 2023 trial found no difference from placebo. Data on the combination with potassium nitrate cover only 3 days.
4. Concentration and conversion to strontium
The table below is a calculation based on the molecular weights in section 1, assuming a pure raw material; actual formulas are calculated from the assay and moisture content on the COA. Total strontium from all permitted strontium compounds must not exceed the limit.
| Level | Conversion (calculated) | Context |
|---|---|---|
| 10% SrCl2·6H2O | about 3.29% strontium | Toothpaste in the Minkoff (1987) and Jang (2023) trials; below the 3.5% limit |
| 3.5% strontium | about 10.65% as hexahydrate or 6.33% as anhydrous | Limit (a): oral hygiene products |
| 2.1% strontium | about 6.39% as hexahydrate or 3.80% as anhydrous | Limit (b): shampoo and face products |
| 2% strontium chloride | 0.66% strontium (if hexahydrate) to 1.11% (if anhydrous) | Liu (2012) toothpaste; abstract does not state the salt form |
5. Use and combinations in the formula
- Daily use: the trials reviewed had participants brush daily, with follow-up from 3 days to 12 weeks.
- Combination with potassium nitrate: only short-term data (Liu & Hu, 2012) and a “low” evidence level (Hu et al., 2018); an additive effect should not be assumed.
- Fluoride: strontium chloride is not a fluoride source; the 10% strontium chloride hexahydrate toothpaste in Jang et al. (2023) has no fluoride in its ingredient list. Butter-C has not found a verified source on compatibility between strontium chloride and sodium fluoride or MFP; if both are needed, stability testing and assay of soluble fluorine on samples are required.
- Abrasives: that toothpaste has calcium carbonate in its base (Jang et al., 2023), so Butter-C does not regard calcium carbonate as an excluded ingredient, but still tests compatibility on real samples.
- A dentist is needed when sensitivity persists, or when caries or a cracked tooth is suspected.
6. Safety: who should take care
- In trials: Liu & Hu (2012) recorded no adverse events over 3 days. In Jang et al. (2023), one person in the strontium group had a lesion on the tongue, diagnosed as a traumatic aphthous ulcer, not an allergy (full text).
- CIR, SCCS: Butter-C has not been able to verify a CIR report or an SCCS opinion specifically on strontium chloride.
- Contact allergy: our PubMed search (November 19, 2026) found no case reports; this does not rule out reactions.
- Raw material: according to the aggregated ECHA C&L notifications on PubChem, 91.5% of 212 reports classify the anhydrous form as causing serious eye damage (H318); for the hexahydrate: 26.3% of 171 reports. Staff weighing the powder need goggles and gloves; raw material packaging must be kept tightly closed.
- Children: none of the trials reviewed was conducted specifically in children; data are insufficient, so consult a dentist.
- Pregnancy and breastfeeding: data are insufficient; consult a doctor.
7. Perspective for brand owners (B2B)
- ASEAN Annex III (version 2026-1, June 22, 2026), Ref 57: scope "(a) Oral hygiene products" and "(b) Shampoo and face products"; limits (a) "3.5% calculated as strontium", (b) "2.1% calculated as strontium"; when combined with other permitted strontium compounds, total strontium must not exceed the corresponding level. The warnings column reads "Contains strontium chloride" and "Frequent use by children is not advisable"; the extract does not assign the warning statements separately to (a) or (b), so Butter-C puts both statements on every product containing strontium chloride (a cautious approach).
- Other strontium salts: Ref 58 (strontium acetate) is for oral hygiene products only, at 3.5% calculated as strontium; Annex II prohibits "Strontium lactate" (Ref 402), "Strontium nitrate" (Ref 403) and "Strontium polycarboxylate" (Ref 404). Annex III also lists strontium hydroxide (Ref 63) and strontium peroxide (Ref 64) for other scopes. Strontium chloride is not in Annex VI (version 2026-1) or Annex VII (version 2025-2).
- Claims: Butter-C uses “helps reduce the sensation of sensitivity in sensitive teeth with regular daily use”, subject to approval by the regulatory team for each dossier; study figures are not borrowed as finished-product efficacy, and there is no promise that sensitivity will disappear immediately. The topical skin data in the dossier consist of only a few studies in healthy people using experimental irritation or itch models, which are not enough for a skin benefit claim.
- Technical file: the COA states the salt form and assay; strontium is assayed in the finished product at the time of manufacture and after aging; the Vietnamese version of the label statements is confirmed by the regulatory team.
Butter-C uses strontium chloride in contract manufacturing of toothpaste for sensitive teeth when a client chooses this positioning, with the strontium content calculated from the COA and labeling according to Ref 57.
Frequently asked questions
Does toothpaste with strontium chloride make sensitivity go away?
That should not be expected. The 1987 trial gave better results than placebo, but the meta-analysis that analyzed the salts separately and the 2023 trial found no difference. Persistent sensitivity needs a dentist’s examination.
How do strontium chloride and strontium acetate differ?
They are two different salts, with two separate entries in ASEAN Annex III (Ref 57 and Ref 58). Results for strontium acetate toothpaste do not apply to strontium chloride.
Why must the label say “Frequent use by children is not advisable”?
Because Ref 57 requires this statement, together with “Contains strontium chloride”. The text does not give a reason.
Can strontium chloride be used in skin care cosmetics?
Under Ref 57, apart from oral hygiene products, it is permitted only in shampoo and face products, at a maximum of 2.1% calculated as strontium. Body lotion, for example, does not fall within this scope.
References
- Minkoff S, Axelrod S. Efficacy of strontium chloride in dental hypersensitivity. J Periodontol. 1987. PMID 3476718
- Jang JH et al. A randomized clinical trial for comparing the efficacy of desensitizing toothpastes on the relief of dentin hypersensitivity. Sci Rep. 2023. PMID 37002263 · full text: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10066268/
- Liu H, Hu D. Efficacy of a commercial dentifrice containing 2% strontium chloride and 5% potassium nitrate for dentin hypersensitivity: a 3-day clinical study in adults in China. Clin Ther. 2012. PMID 22385928 · registration: https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT01426360
- Bae JH et al. Desensitizing toothpaste versus placebo for dentin hypersensitivity: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Clin Periodontol. 2015. PMID 25483802
- Grünberg C et al. Effectiveness of dentifrices with new formulations for the treatment of dentin hypersensitivity - A meta-analysis. Am J Dent. 2017. PMID 29178705
- Hu ML et al. Effect of desensitizing toothpastes on dentine hypersensitivity: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent. 2018. PMID 29787782
- Martins CC et al. Desensitizing Toothpastes for Dentin Hypersensitivity: A Network Meta-analysis. J Dent Res. 2020. PMID 32037944
- NCBI PubChem. Strontium chloride (CID 5362485) https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/5362485 · Strontium chloride hexahydrate (CID 6101868) https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/6101868 · ASEAN Annex II (2026-1): https://asean.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Annex-II-Release_22nd-June-2026-clean.pdf · ASEAN Annex III (2026-1): https://asean.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Annex-III_Release_22nd-June-2026-clean.pdf
BUTTER-C