Steareth-2 and steareth-21: an emulsifier pair in cosmetics
Steareth-2 and steareth-21 often appear side by side on the labels of lotions and roll-on deodorants. They are two ethoxylated emulsifiers made from stearyl alcohol, one lipophilic and one hydrophilic. This article summarizes the CIR conclusion on the alkyl PEG ether group, surveyed use levels, data on the skin barrier, the 1,4-dioxane impurity and what a COA means.
Steareth-2 and steareth-21 (INCI: Steareth-2, Steareth-21) are two nonionic emulsifiers made from stearyl alcohol (an 18-carbon fatty alcohol) bonded to a polyethylene glycol chain: on average 2 ethylene oxide units in steareth-2 and 21 units in steareth-21. The first is lipophilic and the second is hydrophilic, so they are often used as a pair in lotions, creams and roll-on deodorants. Neither is a skin-care active ingredient, and neither is a fatty alcohol (in Vietnamese), even though both share the stearyl backbone.
1. What are steareth-2 and steareth-21?
The CIR (Cosmetic Ingredient Review, US) Expert Panel places the steareths in the alkyl PEG ether group: reaction products of a fatty alcohol with one or more equivalents of ethylene oxide. The group report was published in 2012; the detailed figures in this article are taken from the CIR meeting document of December 2010 (the final draft), because we have not been able to read the full text of the published version. The number in the name is the average number of ethylene oxide units, so each lot is a mixture of molecules with longer and shorter chains.
Steareth-2 was assessed by CIR in 1988; steareth-21 was assessed for the first time in the group report. The two share CAS number 9005-00-9, which covers the whole series; steareth-2 also has CAS number 16057-43-5.
| Criterion | Steareth-2 | Steareth-21 |
|---|---|---|
| Average number of ethylene oxide units | 2 | 21 |
| Molecular weight (CIR, calculated for the average chain) | 358.60 | 1,195.60 |
| HLB | 4.9 (Liu and Lunter, 2020) | no published value in the sources reviewed (steareth-20: 15.3, same source) |
| Uses reported in the US in 2010 | 593 (1986: 107) | 891 |
| Concentration range surveyed in 2010 | 0.008–10% | 0.01–7% |
2. Why the two are often used as a pair
HLB (hydrophilic–lipophilic balance) indicates whether a surfactant leans toward water or toward oil. Liu and Lunter (2020) give an HLB of 4.9 for steareth-2 and 15.3 for steareth-20 (20 ethylene oxide units, one fewer than steareth-21). The sources reviewed do not give an HLB for steareth-21; the HLB of each lot is taken from the supplier’s technical data sheet.
A published example of this pair: Montenegro et al. (2008) used a steareth-2, steareth-21 and cetearyl alcohol system as one of five emulsifier systems for oil-in-water sunscreen creams. The sources reviewed give no standard ratio between the two steareths; the ratio and the total amount of emulsifier must be determined by testing each formula.
3. Typical concentrations and product types
The table below is drawn from data voluntarily reported to the FDA and from a 2010 industry concentration survey, as given in the CIR meeting document of December 2010. These are levels in use in the US, not legal limits or recommendations.
| Category (CIR, 2010) | Steareth-2 | Steareth-21 |
|---|---|---|
| Leave-on | 527 uses; 0.1–5% | 379 uses; 0.01–7% |
| Rinse-off | 66 uses; 0.008–10% | 512 uses; 0.04–5% |
| Underarm deodorants | 58 uses; 0.5–3% | 19 uses; 0.8–2% |
| Hand and body creams, lotions | 0.3–3% | 0.9–3% |
| Face and neck creams, lotions | 0.4–5% | 0.9–4% |
| Eye area | 59 uses; 0.2–3% | 43 uses; 0.4–2% |
| Hair dye products | 1 use; 0.8–3% | 388 uses; 0.5–5% |
4. Effects on the skin barrier and on the penetration of other substances
On human skin. Bárány et al. (2000) tested nine emulsifiers, including steareth-2, steareth-10 and steareth-21, at 5% in a 50:50 water–mineral oil mixture, applied under occlusion in aluminum chambers. According to the study summary in the CIR meeting document, on normal skin (20 subjects, 48 hours) all three steareths caused a statistically significant increase in transepidermal water loss (TEWL) compared with the vehicle, but did not cause more redness and did not change skin blood flow. On skin pre-irritated with sodium lauryl sulfate (27 subjects, 17 hours), steareth-2 and steareth-21 instead decreased TEWL compared with the vehicle. The authors suggested that the emulsifiers may enter the lipid bilayers. The first author’s contact email uses the domain of a cosmetics company. This was a short-term occlusive test with single substances.
On excised pig skin. Liu and Lunter (2020) used Raman spectroscopy to measure stratum corneum lipids after 4 hours of exposure to a solution or dispersion of each emulsifier. The PEG-2 ether of stearyl alcohol (that is, steareth-2) did not change the amount of lipids and did not shift the lipids into a less ordered state, whereas the PEG-20 ethers (including steareth-20) reduced the amount of lipids the most. The study did not test steareth-21, so the results for the PEG-20 substances are not extrapolated to steareth-21.
Penetration of UV filters. On excised human skin (in vitro, 22 hours), Montenegro et al. (2008) compared five sunscreen creams that differed only in their emulsifier system. The cream with steareth-2, steareth-21 and cetearyl alcohol gave the lowest permeation of octyl methoxycinnamate, about nine times lower than the cream with the highest permeation; butyl methoxydibenzoylmethane permeation was also significantly lower. The result belongs to the whole formula, not to the two steareths alone.
The CIR Panel noted in general that some alkyl PEG ethers may enhance the penetration of other substances, so caution is needed when combining them with ingredients whose safety relies on low skin absorption. This note applies to the whole group and is not based on data specific to the two steareths.
5. Safety: who should take note
CIR conclusion. According to the abstract of the version published in 2012, the Panel concluded that the alkyl PEG ethers are “safe as used when formulated to be nonirritating”; the list in the December 2010 meeting document includes both steareth-2 and steareth-21. For ingredients without data of their own, conclusions were inferred from data on other ingredients in the same group.
Data specific to steareth-2 (summary of the 1988 report in the CIR meeting document): in animals, steareth-2 at up to 60% and formulations containing up to 2.75% caused at most mild skin irritation; in humans, steareth-2 at 60% was not a primary irritant, one 0.6% formulation caused mild irritation, and steareth-2 was not a primary sensitizer. Steareth-21 has no irritation or sensitization data of its own in the meeting document apart from the TEWL study in section 4; its safety conclusion rests on group data.
Damaged skin. Older reports advised against using ingredients with a PEG chain on damaged skin, out of concern that PEGs could penetrate and harm the kidneys. The December 2010 CIR meeting document records that this caveat has been removed; the concern now applies only to severely burned skin.
Oxidized raw material. Bergh et al. (1998) found that a high-purity alcohol ethoxylate did not cause significant sensitization in guinea pigs, but when it was stored at room temperature, the levels of peroxides and formaldehyde in the material rose over time; cold storage limited this. The test substance was not a steareth, but steareths are also ethoxylated alcohols, so the raw material should be kept tightly closed and away from heat.
Pregnant women. The sources reviewed contain no data specific to steareth-2 or steareth-21; the data are insufficient, so consult a doctor.
6. 1,4-Dioxane, ethylene oxide and the COA
According to the CIR meeting document, alkyl PEG ethers are usually manufactured by reacting ethylene oxide with a fatty alcohol under alkaline catalysis, and 1,4-dioxane is commonly formed as a by-product. This is a process impurity, not an inherent property of the steareth molecule. An FDA survey (Black et al., 2001) found 1,4-dioxane at up to 1,410 ppm in ethoxylated raw materials and up to 279 ppm in finished products. The CIR Panel stressed that the industry must continue to remove 1,4-dioxane and ethylene oxide from raw materials before they are used in formulations.
ASEAN Annex II (version 2026-1) has entries for “Ethylene oxide”, CAS 75-21-8 (Ref 182) and “Dioxane”, CAS 123-91-1 (Ref 343). Điều 14 (Article 14) of Thông tư 06/2011/TT-BYT (Circular 06/2011/TT-BYT, Vietnam’s Ministry of Health circular on cosmetic product management; linked article in Vietnamese) accepts substances listed in Annex II at trace levels if their presence is technically unavoidable under good manufacturing practice and the cosmetic remains safe. The ASEAN guidelines on limits of contaminants set 1,4-dioxane at no more than 10 ppm from June 19, 2023, applied when finished products are analyzed in post-market surveillance.
Butter-C therefore requires a COA (certificate of analysis for the lot) with results for 1,4-dioxane, ethylene oxide and peroxide value, kept in the Product Information File. A COA covers only the raw material lot and does not replace results on the finished product; “not detected” means below the limit of detection, not zero.
7. Perspective for brand owners (B2B)
- ASEAN regulations: searched by name and CAS number, steareth-2 and steareth-21 are not listed in Annexes II, III, VI (version 2026-1) or VII (version 2025-2), so there are no specific concentration limits or label warnings.
- Deodorant and antiperspirant roll-ons: the sources reviewed contain no stability data specific to the steareth pair with aluminum salts such as aluminum chlorohydrate (in Vietnamese); stability testing at elevated temperature is needed, monitoring phase separation, viscosity, pH and corrosion of the roller ball.
- Labeling: a product containing steareths should not be labeled “PEG-free”, as with ceteareth-25 (in Vietnamese); a “free of 1,4-dioxane” claim requires analytical results on the finished product.
Butter-C uses the steareth-2 and steareth-21 pair or other emulsifier systems in the contract manufacturing of roll-on deodorants and lotions, selects the ratio through stability testing and requires an impurity COA for each lot.
Frequently asked questions
Are steareth-2 and steareth-21 safe in cosmetics?
CIR concluded that the alkyl PEG ether group, including both ingredients, is safe as used when formulated to be nonirritating. The points to control are the impurities 1,4-dioxane and ethylene oxide, and oxidized raw material.
Why do both often appear on the label at the same time?
Steareth-2 is lipophilic (HLB 4.9) and steareth-21 is hydrophilic (long ethylene oxide chain; steareth-20 has an HLB of 15.3). Used together, the two give an emulsifier system with both a lipophilic and a hydrophilic part, as in published formulas; the ratio is decided by each formula.
Do steareths damage the skin barrier?
In a 48-hour occlusive test with single substances at 5%, all three steareths tested increased TEWL on normal skin but did not cause more redness than the vehicle. On excised pig skin, steareth-2 did not change stratum corneum lipids. There are no long-term studies with finished products yet.
Do products containing steareths contain 1,4-dioxane?
Traces from the raw material manufacturing process may be present; this is controlled through a COA for each lot and by checking the finished product against the 10 ppm level in the ASEAN guidelines.
References
- Cosmetic Ingredient Review. Final Report (Draft) on Alkyl PEG Ethers, CIR Expert Panel meeting document, December 13–14, 2010 (final draft, not the official published version). https://www.cir-safety.org/sites/default/files/117_final_alkyl.pdf
- Fiume MM et al. Safety assessment of alkyl PEG ethers as used in cosmetics. Int J Toxicol. 2012. PMID 23064774
- Bárány E et al. Unexpected skin barrier influence from nonionic emulsifiers. Int J Pharm. 2000. PMID 10675696
- Liu Y, Lunter DJ. Systematic Investigation of the Effect of Non-Ionic Emulsifiers on Skin by Confocal Raman Spectroscopy-A Comprehensive Lipid Analysis. Pharmaceutics. 2020. PMID 32131544
- Montenegro L et al. In vitro skin permeation of sunscreen agents from O/W emulsions. Int J Cosmet Sci. 2008. PMID 18377631
- Bergh M et al. Formation of formaldehyde and peroxides by air oxidation of high purity polyoxyethylene surfactants. Contact Dermatitis. 1998. PMID 9686972
- Black RE et al. Occurrence of 1,4-dioxane in cosmetic raw materials and finished cosmetic products. J AOAC Int. 2001. PMID 11417628
- ASEAN Cosmetic Committee. ASEAN Guidelines on Limits of Contaminants for Cosmetics (Release Version 3.0). https://file.go.gov.sg/asean-guidelines-on-limits-of-contaminants-for-cosmetics.pdf
BUTTER-C