Cosmetic fragrance allergy: labels, essential oils, “unscented”
According to DermNet, fragrance allergy is second only to nickel allergy among the causes of allergic contact dermatitis. This article explains the mechanism, compares ASEAN and EU labeling rules, and points out what to read on the label once you know you are allergic.
Fragrance in cosmetics is an ingredient group that often causes contact allergy: according to DermNet, fragrance allergy is second only to nickel allergy among the causes of allergic contact dermatitis. On a label, a single word such as “Parfum” or “Fragrance” can stand for a mixture of many substances, and users usually do not know what that mixture contains.
This article compares the fragrance labeling rules of ASEAN and the European Union (EU), distinguishes “fragrance-free” from “unscented,” and explains why essential oils also contain allergens. How to tell irritation from allergy, and patch testing, are covered in the article on cosmetic contact dermatitis.
1. What fragrance in cosmetics consists of
Fragrances can be extracted from natural sources or synthesized; they create a pleasant scent or mask the unpleasant odor of other ingredients (DermNet). The review by Sukakul et al. (2024) cites the European definition: a fragrance is a complex mixture that may contain up to several hundred fragrance ingredients. A fragrance ingredient can be a single substance, for example linalool or benzyl alcohol, or a natural mixture, for example lavender essential oil.
Besides perfumes, DermNet lists fragrance in body washes, shampoos, deodorants, wet wipes, lip balms, toothpastes and laundry detergents.
2. Why fragrance often causes allergic contact dermatitis
Fragrance allergy is a delayed hypersensitivity reaction: once the skin has become sensitized to a substance, each new exposure can cause inflammation after a few hours to a few days (DermNet). Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 states explicitly that once a person is sensitized, a much lower concentration is enough to cause symptoms.
Frequency varies with the population and the test series used. According to de Groot (2020), up to 4.5% of adults in the general population may be allergic to fragrance, and the rate may reach 20–25% among consecutive patients patch tested for suspected contact dermatitis; more than 150 fragrance substances have caused contact allergy. DermNet reports fragrance allergy in about 10% of people who are patch tested.
One difficulty is that many fragrance substances become allergens only after they are transformed. Linalool and limonene, two very common fragrance substances, rarely cause sensitization in their original form, but air oxidizes them into sensitizing hydroperoxides (Sukakul et al., 2024). De Groot (2020) classifies these hydroperoxides as frequent sensitizers, along with oak moss extract, tree moss extract, isoeugenol, cinnamyl alcohol and cinnamal.
According to European general-population data compiled by Sukakul et al. (2024), leave-on products are the most significant source of fragrance sensitization; de Groot (2020) names deodorants, perfumes and aftershave products as products that commonly initiate sensitization.
3. Recognizing fragrance allergy
According to DermNet, fragrance allergy usually appears as red, scaly, itchy patches of skin that may burn, swell or blister, or as streaks exactly where the skin was in contact. Common sites in women are the hands, face and neck; in men, the hands, face and lower legs; the armpits are affected in both sexes.
Diagnosis requires patch testing by a dermatologist. The baseline series usually includes fragrance mix I, fragrance mix II and balsam of Peru; the doctor may also test individual fragrance substances, essential oils or the products the patient brings in (Sukakul et al., 2024).
4. Fragrance labeling: ASEAN documents and EU regulation
Under the ASEAN Cosmetic Labeling Requirements (Appendix II, version dated September 4, 2007; not Annex II of the ASEAN Cosmetic Directive, the list of prohibited substances), the ingredient list must be complete, but a perfume or aromatic composition and its raw materials may be declared collectively with a single word: “perfume,” “fragrance,” “aroma” or “flavor.” Botanical ingredients are declared by their genus and species names.
Annex III of the ASEAN Cosmetic Directive (Release Version 2026-1, June 22, 2026) contains no list of fragrance allergens that must be named individually: entries 67 to 92 read “Entries left intentionally blank.” Thus, under these two documents, a label may say only “Fragrance” without listing linalool, limonene or other allergens. This article compares only the ASEAN documents; national rules of individual countries, if any, need to be checked separately.
Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 states that the EU already required 24 fragrance allergens to be named individually, and adds 56 new entries, including some essential oils and extracts; in total, 80 substances must be labeled (Sukakul et al., 2024). The original list had 26 substances; two of them were later banned in the EU (Sukakul et al., 2024). A substance must be named individually when it exceeds 0.001% in leave-on products or 0.01% in rinse-off products. Products that do not meet the new requirements could be placed on the EU market only until July 31, 2026 (a date that has now passed) and may remain on sale until July 31, 2028.
| Item | ASEAN (labeling Appendix II; Annex III, version 2026-1) | EU (Regulation 2023/1545) |
|---|---|---|
| Collective name for a fragrance mixture | perfume, fragrance, aroma or flavor | parfum or aroma |
| List of fragrance allergens that must be named individually | None (entries 67–92 left blank) | 24 existing substances, plus 56 new entries (80 substances in total) |
| Threshold for individual naming | Not specified | Above 0.001% (leave-on), above 0.01% (rinse-off) |
Even a complete label does not show how much hydroperoxide forms when linalool and limonene oxidize; finding out requires chemical analysis (Sukakul et al., 2024). The other mandatory label information is covered in the article on cosmetic labeling rules (in Vietnamese).
5. “Fragrance-free” and “unscented” are not the same
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) notes that some products labeled “unscented” still contain fragrance, added in just the amount needed to mask the unpleasant odor of other ingredients. DermNet advises people with fragrance allergy to choose products labeled “fragrance-free,” but reminds them that such products may still contain masking fragrance.
| Label wording | What to know | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| “Unscented” | The product has no noticeable scent but may still contain masking fragrance (FDA) | Read the ingredient list; look for Parfum, Fragrance, Aroma and essential oil names |
| “Fragrance-free” | Suggested by DermNet, but may still contain masking fragrance | Still read the ingredient list |
| “Natural,” “herbal” | May contain fragrance that is not named (DermNet) | Check the plant names in the ingredient list |
| No ingredient list | There is no way to know what the product contains | People already allergic to fragrance should avoid it (DermNet) |
6. Essential oils contain allergens too
“Natural” does not mean non-allergenic. According to the review by de Groot and Schmidt (2016), nearly 80 essential oils have caused contact allergy. Of 55 oils patch tested in people with suspected contact dermatitis, nine gave positive rates above 2%, including orange, tea tree, citronella, ylang-ylang and clove. Most reactions occurred when undiluted essential oils or high-concentration products were applied. People allergic to one essential oil also often react to other essential oils and to fragrance mixes, partly because they share constituents.
According to the summary table by Sukakul et al. (2024), ylang-ylang oil contains linalool and geraniol, and peppermint oil contains limonene and linalool; all three substances are on the EU’s original labeling list (DermNet). The authors note that essential oil names on labels (the Latin names of the plants) are easily taken to be “plant extracts” rather than fragrance, and that essential oils are used more often in products marketed as “natural.” A detailed example is given in the article on lavender essential oil in cosmetics (in Vietnamese).
7. Checklist for people who suspect or know they are allergic to fragrance
- Recurrent itchy rash on the face, neck, armpits or hands: see a dermatologist for patch testing.
- Write down the exact name of the substance that tested positive, because one substance can have several names.
- Favor products labeled “fragrance-free,” and still read the ingredient list: look for Parfum, Fragrance, Aroma, Flavor and essential oil names.
- Avoid products without an ingredient list (DermNet).
- Before using a new scented leave-on product: DermNet suggests applying a dot to the same spot on the forearm twice a day for two weeks; if a rash appears, do not use the product.
- Swollen eyelids or lips, blisters, a widespread rash: see a doctor promptly; topical or oral medicines, if needed, are prescription medicines prescribed by the doctor.
From a formulation perspective, Butter-C recommends formulas without added fragrance for soothing product lines, for example a soothing, skin-protecting essence; products sold into the EU must declare fragrance allergens under EU regulations. A fragrance-free formula can still cause allergy because of other ingredients.
Frequently asked questions
Is a product labeled “unscented” suitable for people with fragrance allergy?
Not necessarily. According to the FDA, some products labeled “unscented” still contain fragrance to mask the odor of ingredients; read the ingredient list.
Are natural essential oils gentler than synthetic fragrances?
Not necessarily. Nearly 80 essential oils have caused contact allergy, especially when used undiluted or at high concentrations (de Groot and Schmidt, 2016).
Why do many labels just say “Fragrance”?
The ASEAN documents allow a fragrance mixture to be declared collectively with one word and have no list of fragrance allergens that must be named individually. The EU, by contrast, requires individual naming above the thresholds.
References
- de Groot AC. Fragrances: Contact Allergy and Other Adverse Effects. Dermatitis. 2020. PMID 31433384
- Sukakul T et al. Fragrance Contact Allergy - A Review Focusing on Patch Testing. Acta Derm Venereol. 2024. PMID 39140486
- de Groot AC, Schmidt E. Essential Oils, Part IV: Contact Allergy. Dermatitis. 2016. PMID 27427818
- DermNet. Fragrance allergy. https://dermnetnz.org/topics/fragrance-allergy
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Fragrances in Cosmetics. https://www.fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetic-ingredients/fragrances-cosmetics
- ASEAN. Appendix II: ASEAN Cosmetic Labeling Requirements (4 September 2007). https://file.go.gov.sg/appendix-ii-asean-cosmetic-labelling-requirements.pdf
- ASEAN. ASEAN Cosmetic Directive, Annex III – List of substances which cosmetic products must not contain except subject to restrictions and conditions laid down, Release Version 2026-1, 22nd June 2026 (entries 67 to 92). https://asean.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Annex-III_Release_22nd-June-2026-clean.pdf
- European Commission. Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 of 26 July 2023 amending Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 as regards labelling of fragrance allergens in cosmetic products. Official Journal of the European Union, L 188, 27.7.2023. https://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/d2ce789e-2c4b-11ee-95a2-01aa75ed71a1.0006.03/DOC_1
BUTTER-C