Exfoliating correctly: mechanical, chemical and sun protection
Exfoliation can help skin feel smoother, but done the wrong way it leaves skin red, stinging, dry and prone to dark marks. Choosing a method that suits your skin type, exfoliating infrequently and protecting your skin carefully from the sun matter more than choosing a strong product.
Exfoliation means making the dead cells in the outermost layer of the skin come off, either by scrubbing (mechanical) or by using active ingredients (chemical). Done correctly, it can make skin look smoother; overdone, it can leave skin red and stinging, drier, or with more breakouts. According to the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD), exfoliation is not suitable for everyone, and exfoliating incorrectly can do more harm than good.
Details on each active ingredient are covered in separate ingredient articles.
1. Why skin does (or does not) need exfoliation
The stratum corneum sheds and renews itself in a cycle even without any external intervention (see the article skin structure). The AAD notes that some people believe exfoliation makes their skin look better; anyone who chooses to exfoliate needs to do it safely so that it does not damage the skin, make the skin redder or cause more breakouts.
2. Mechanical and chemical exfoliation
The AAD divides at-home exfoliation into two groups: mechanical, which uses a tool (brush, pad, sponge) or a product containing particles to scrub off dead cells; and chemical, which uses acids such as AHAs and BHAs to dissolve dead cells.
| Group | Examples | What is known |
|---|---|---|
| Mechanical | Products with scrubbing particles, brushes, pads, sponges | May be too irritating for dry, sensitive or acne-prone skin (AAD) |
| AHA | Glycolic acid, lactic acid | Exfoliate the surface layer of the skin; the degree of exfoliation depends on the type of AHA, its concentration, the pH and the other ingredients in the product (FDA) |
| BHA | Salicylic acid | Exfoliates the stratum corneum; is comedolytic; acts by loosening the bonds between cells rather than breaking down keratin filaments (Arif, 2015) |
| PHA | Gluconolactone | Described by the authors as providing the benefits of AHAs without causing irritation, with an added moisturizing effect (Green et al., 2009) |
| Enzymes | Papain, bromelain | Proteolytic enzymes mimic the natural shedding (desquamation) process; clinical data are still very limited (Trevisol et al., 2022) |
Additional notes:
- PHA: the first author of the review by Green et al. (2009) worked for a cosmetics company (a potential conflict of interest); the statement “without causing irritation” is the authors' opinion. A study comparing gluconolactone with glycolic acid is covered in the article gluconolactone (PHA) (in Vietnamese).
- Enzymes: the review by Trevisol et al. (2022) found only 11 articles, with very few clinical trials. According to the authors, enzyme activity depends on pH, temperature and stability in the formula; the risk of allergy and irritation needs to be kept in mind, and more rigorous in vivo research is needed.
- Plastic beads: in the United States, the Microbead-Free Waters Act of 2015 prohibits the manufacture and distribution of rinse-off cosmetics containing plastic microbeads used for exfoliation or cleansing. According to the FDA, the law is intended to protect water resources; the FDA has no evidence that plastic microbeads in cosmetics harm the health of users.
3. Choosing an exfoliation method by skin type
The AAD advises identifying your skin type before choosing an exfoliation method, because not every method suits every skin type:
| Skin type (per the AAD) | AAD suggestion |
|---|---|
| Sensitive: stinging or burning after using products | A washcloth and a mild chemical exfoliant may be all that is needed; mechanical exfoliation may be too irritating |
| Dry: flaky, itchy, rough | Same as sensitive skin |
| Acne-prone | Same as sensitive skin |
| Oily, thick: shiny | Can use stronger chemical products or mechanical exfoliation |
| Darker skin tone, or prone to dark marks after burns, insect bites or acne | Avoid strong chemical or mechanical exfoliation, which may increase pigmentation and leave dark spots |
If you are not sure which skin type you have, the AAD advises asking a dermatologist.
4. Concentration, pH and regulations
In ASEAN, commonly used exfoliating acids have specific limits in Annex III of the ASEAN Cosmetic Directive (version 2026-1):
- Glycolic acid, lactic acid and their salts and simple esters (Ref A6): skin products for general use, maximum 10% in total, calculated as the acids, with a final product pH of 3.5 or higher. Levels above 10% up to 20% (pH 3.0 or higher) are for professional use only; levels above 20% are for use by qualified medical practitioners only. The label must carry a sunburn warning when the product contains 2.5% or more and contains no sunscreen, except for products intended for skin areas that are not exposed to the sun.
- Salicylic acid (Ref 98): maximum 2.0% for most products, including facial skin products; 0.5% for body lotions, lipsticks, eye makeup products and a few other categories; not to be used for children under 3 years of age and not to be used in forms that may be inhaled into the lungs. These limits already include any salicylic acid used as a preservative.
Mandelic acid, gluconolactone and papain have no specific limit entries in these annexes. In the United States, the FDA cites the conclusion of the CIR Expert Panel (an industry self-regulatory body, relying on industry-funded studies) that products containing glycolic acid or lactic acid are safe for consumers when the AHA concentration does not exceed 10%, the final product pH is 3.5 or higher, and the product either contains sun protection or carries directions for daily sun protection. Data on each ingredient can be found in the articles glycolic acid (in Vietnamese) and salicylic acid (BHA) (in Vietnamese).
5. Signs of over-exfoliation
The AAD warns that exfoliating too much can make skin red and irritated. From 1992 to February 2004, the FDA received 114 reports of adverse skin reactions associated with AHA-containing products, including burning (45), dermatitis or rash (35), swelling (29), pigmentation changes (15), blisters or welts (14), skin peeling (13), itching (12) and chemical burns (6). Severe reactions occurred most often with strongly exfoliating products such as “peels”.
Checklist: stop exfoliating when (compiled from AAD and FDA)
- Redness, burning or stinging persists after using the product.
- Skin feels tight and dry, with more flaking than before.
- Breakouts increase after you start exfoliating.
- New dark spots appear in the exfoliated area.
- The skin has cuts or open wounds, or is sunburned — the AAD advises against exfoliating in these cases.
When this happens, pause the exfoliating product, cleanse gently and moisturize regularly. If the skin blisters, swells, hurts or does not improve after a few days, see a dermatologist.
6. Exfoliation and sun protection
AHAs make skin more sensitive to UV radiation. In the randomized, double-blind trial by Kaidbey et al. (2003), 29 white participants applied 10% glycolic acid (pH 3.5) or a placebo to their backs daily, 6 days a week for 4 weeks. The sites where glycolic acid was applied reddened at a lower UV dose and had more sunburn cells; according to the FDA, sensitivity to UV-induced redness increased by 18% and UV-induced cell damage doubled on average, with large differences between individuals. One week after application stopped, the differences were no longer present.
In the study by Kornhauser et al. (2009) in 14 people, with application to the back for 3.5 weeks, 10% glycolic acid increased redness, DNA damage and sunburn cells after exposure to simulated solar radiation; 2% salicylic acid did not significantly change these measures. Both studies were small and were conducted on the skin of the back.
The label warning that the FDA recommends for cosmetics containing AHAs advises: use a sunscreen, wear protective clothing and limit sun exposure while using the product and for one week afterward.
7. How to exfoliate safely at home
- Review the products you already use: prescription retinoids, retinol and benzoyl peroxide also make the skin sensitive or cause peeling; adding exfoliation may make the skin drier and even cause breakouts (AAD).
- Be gentle: with a scrub or a wash-off chemical exfoliant, apply gently in small circular motions for about 30 seconds, then rinse off with lukewarm water, not hot water; with a brush or sponge, use short, light strokes (AAD).
- Moisturize right afterward, because exfoliation can dry out the skin (AAD).
- Frequency: depends on skin type and exfoliation method; the stronger the method, the less often it should be used (AAD).
- Add only one new product at a time and watch your skin for a few weeks before adding another product (practical suggestion).
8. A formulation perspective
When developing exfoliating products, the Butter-C formulation team controls particle size and particle hardness for mechanical formats, and concentration, final product pH and the sunburn warning statement for acid formats, in line with ASEAN Annex III. Claims stop at “helps clear away dead skin cells, for smoother skin”, together with a sun protection recommendation.
Frequently asked questions
How often should you exfoliate?
There is no universal schedule. According to the AAD, frequency depends on skin type and exfoliation method; the stronger the method, the less often it should be used. Red, stinging skin is a sign to cut back or stop.
Should people with darker skin exfoliate strongly to make their skin brighter?
No. The AAD notes that for people with darker skin, strong exfoliation methods can increase pigmentation and leave dark spots. Choose a gentle method and use sun protection consistently.
Does salicylic acid make skin sun-sensitive the way AHAs do?
In a small study of 14 people, 2% salicylic acid did not significantly increase the skin's sensitivity to simulated solar radiation, unlike 10% glycolic acid (Kornhauser et al., 2009). Even so, daily sun protection is still advisable.
References
- American Academy of Dermatology. How to safely exfoliate at home. https://www.aad.org/public/everyday-care/skin-care-secrets/routine/safely-exfoliate-at-home
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Alpha Hydroxy Acids. https://www.fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetic-ingredients/alpha-hydroxy-acids
- Kaidbey K et al. Topical glycolic acid enhances photodamage by ultraviolet light. Photodermatol Photoimmunol Photomed. 2003. PMID 12713551.
- Kornhauser A et al. The effects of topically applied glycolic acid and salicylic acid on ultraviolet radiation-induced erythema, DNA damage and sunburn cell formation in human skin. J Dermatol Sci. 2009. PMID 19411163.
- Arif T. Salicylic acid as a peeling agent: a comprehensive review. Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol. 2015. PMID 26347269.
- Green BA et al. Clinical and cosmeceutical uses of hydroxyacids. Clin Dermatol. 2009. PMID 19695482.
- Trevisol TC et al. An overview of the use of proteolytic enzymes as exfoliating agents. J Cosmet Dermatol. 2022. PMID 34897928.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The Microbead-Free Waters Act: FAQs. https://www.fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetics-laws-regulations/microbead-free-waters-act-faqs
BUTTER-C