Skin science

20/11/2026 9 min read

Cosmetics that cause acne and comedogenic ratings: choose wisely

Comedogenicity rating tables and “non-comedogenic” labels help people with acne-prone skin choose products, but most of the figures come from testing raw materials on rabbit ears. Knowing how they are measured helps you read labels with the right expectations.

Cosmetics that cause acne and comedogenic ratings: choose wisely
A foundation bottle, a concealer tube and a makeup sponge — product types people often ask about for their potential to cause comedones

Cosmetic-induced acne (acne cosmetica) is the term for comedones and acne that appear because of products applied to the skin, such as moisturizers, foundation and hair pomade. This led to “comedogenicity” rating tables (the potential to cause comedones) for individual ingredients and to “non-comedogenic” labels (not causing comedones) on packaging. This article explains how those numbers are measured, their limits, and how to choose products when your skin is acne-prone.

1. What is acne cosmetica

Comedogenicity is the ability of a substance to make the cells lining the hair follicle keratinize and shed abnormally, leading to partial blockage of the follicle (open comedones, blackheads) or complete blockage (closed comedones, whiteheads). The comedogenic potential of topical products was reported by Kligman and Mills as early as 1972 (Waranuch et al., 2021). The general mechanism of blockage is covered in our article on blackheads and whiteheads.

According to DermNet, factors that may contribute to comedone formation include excessive “hydration” of the skin from moisturizers or a humid environment, and exposure to oily hair pomades, isopropyl myristate, propylene glycol and certain colorants in cosmetics. Cosmetics are only one of many factors; hormones, sebum and cigarette smoking also contribute.

Are cosmetics in general a main cause of acne? A case-control study in India compared 910 people with post-adolescent acne with 910 people without acne: people who used more cosmetics actually had lower odds of acne, although some individual types of cosmetics had odds ratios greater than 1 (Singh et al., 2013). This is an observational study and does not prove cause and effect. The authors concluded that the term “acne cosmetica” remains appropriate in the sense that some cosmetics can cause acne.

2. How comedogenicity ratings began: rabbit ear testing

The rabbit ear model applies the test substance to the rabbit’s external ear canal and then assesses the increase in follicular keratinization (Nguyen et al., 2007). Fulton et al. (1984) used this model to test many ingredients and finished products. The authors themselves described the rabbit ear assay as “not an ideal animal model” but used it because no more suitable model was available at the time. The ingredients that tested positive in the study included isopropyl myristate and similar esters, some lanolin derivatives (acetylated, ethoxylated) and the D&C red colorants tested.

Nguyen et al. (2007) tested 14 ingredients on rabbit ears: 9 ingredients were positive, including isopropyl myristate, isopropyl palmitate, butyl stearate and cocoa butter; cetyl alcohol, paraffin, stearyl alcohol, sodium lauryl sulfate and petrolatum were not classified as positive. Rabbit ear tests of this kind usually use the raw material neat, undiluted (Waranuch et al., 2021). An analysis of one individual ingredient is available in our article on isopropyl myristate (in Vietnamese).

3. Limits of ingredient rating tables

  • Rabbit ears are more sensitive than human skin. Mills and Kligman (1982) noted that substances that are moderately to strongly comedogenic on rabbit ears may cause comedones in the human model, but substances that are only weakly comedogenic on rabbit ears are probably safe for people, possibly except for those who are acne-prone.
  • A neat raw material differs from a finished product. In a formula, an ingredient is combined with many other components and then applied to human skin, so the comedogenicity of the finished product may differ from the result for the ingredient (Waranuch et al., 2021).
  • Finished products need to be tested separately. Draelos and DiNardo (2006) tested finished products on the backs of 6 people prone to forming comedones and concluded that finished products containing ingredients rated as comedogenic are not necessarily comedogenic.
  • A table that does not cite its sources cannot be checked. A number is meaningful only when the test model, concentration and test vehicle are known. That is why this article does not include an ingredient ranking table.

4. Comparison of test models

ModelMethodLimitations
Rabbit earIngredient or finished product applied to rabbit ears; follicular hyperkeratinization assessedMore sensitive than human skin; usually tests neat raw materials
Human back (Mills and Kligman, 1982)Test substance applied under occlusion for one month on the upper back of young Black men with large follicles; comedones collected with cyanoacrylate glue and then assessedNarrow participant group; the back differs from facial skin
Human back, modified (Draelos and DiNardo, 2006)6 people with visible follicular openings who readily form comedones; patches soaked with 0.2–0.5 mL of finished product, 3 times a week for 4 weeks; microcomedones countedVery small sample size; only a few products can be tested
Human back, controlled (Waranuch et al., 2021)15 Thai men, double-blind, randomized; positive control (octyl palmitate) and negative control (blank patch)12 people analyzed; responses varied between individuals

In the study by Waranuch et al. (2021), a product that increased the microcomedone count by less than 50% from baseline was considered non-comedogenic; the positive control had to increase the microcomedone count 1.5- to 2-fold. Of the 15 people initially recruited, 3 had to stop partway through because of skin irritation from the adhesive tape and were replaced by new participants; 1 person stopped for personal reasons. Of the 14 people who completed the study, 2 responded differently than expected to the positive or negative control and were excluded from the analysis. All test products met the threshold. One co-author worked at a research institute of the manufacturer of the products tested. The authors noted that the test site should match the characteristics of the finished product, because responses in different skin areas do not correlate closely.

5. “Non-comedogenic” labels: what they can and cannot tell you

A “non-comedogenic” or “won’t clog pores” label is the manufacturer’s claim that the product does not cause comedones. According to the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD), these products do not cause breakouts in most people, which means they are not guaranteed for everyone. What the label cannot tell you:

  • The level of proof: whether the finished product was tested or the claim was only inferred from the ingredient list; how many people were tested, and on which skin area.
  • Your own reaction: a small study showed that responses vary between individuals (Waranuch et al., 2021).
  • How the product is used: the AAD notes that even non-comedogenic makeup can cause acne if it is left on overnight, and that sharing makeup, brushes or sponges can lead to breakouts.

The results of Draelos and DiNardo (2006) show why a “non-comedogenic” claim should be based on test data for the finished product itself, not only on the formula “avoiding” the ingredients in a ranking table. Waranuch et al. (2021) also recommend testing the finished product.

6. How to choose and monitor products for acne-prone skin

The checklist below is based on recommendations from the AAD and DermNet, plus some practical suggestions:

  • Choose makeup, sunscreen, skin care and hair care products labeled “non-comedogenic” or “won’t clog pores” (AAD).
  • Remove makeup before bed, without exception (AAD). How to combine makeup remover and cleanser is covered in our article on double cleansing.
  • Do not share makeup, brushes or sponges (AAD).
  • Wash your face twice a day and after sweating, with a gentle, non-comedogenic cleanser; do not scrub (AAD).
  • Do not let your skin become dry and tight: use a moisturizer made for acne-prone skin (AAD); DermNet notes that over-hydration of the skin from moisturizers may contribute to comedones, so a thin layer is enough (practical suggestion).
  • Choose non-comedogenic hair waxes and oils (AAD); DermNet lists oily hair pomades among the factors that may contribute to comedones.
  • Add only one new product at a time and monitor for a few weeks; note down the product and the areas where breakouts appear to identify a suspect product (practical suggestion).

Not every bump that appears after you use a new product is a comedone; itching, redness and burning suggest irritation or allergy. According to the AAD, deep, painful acne needs to be examined by a dermatologist; acne that persists despite proper care should also be checked by a doctor. See also our article on caring for acne-prone skin.

7. Formulation perspective

When developing formulas for oily, acne-prone skin, the Butter-C formulation team regards rabbit ear data as a signal to consider early, not as a conclusion about the finished product. The statement “non-comedogenic” should go on the label only when the finished product itself has been tested on people, with the method and assessment threshold recorded in the product file.

Frequently asked questions

A product labeled “non-comedogenic” still gives me breakouts. Why?

Tests are usually done on small groups, against a set threshold (Draelos and DiNardo, 2006; Waranuch et al., 2021); the AAD also says only that these products do not cause acne in most people. How the product is used (leaving it on overnight, sharing brushes) also matters. If breakouts recur whenever you use a product, stop using that product and monitor your skin.

Should I look up the comedogenicity rating of every ingredient?

Rating tables come mainly from testing raw materials on rabbit ears, a model that is more sensitive than human skin (Mills and Kligman, 1982). Finished products containing ingredients rated as “comedogenic” are not necessarily comedogenic (Draelos and DiNardo, 2006).

Should people with oily, acne-prone skin skip moisturizer to avoid clogging?

No. The AAD notes that dry skin is irritated skin, and irritation can lead to more breakouts. Choose a moisturizer made for acne-prone skin with a light texture, such as a moisturizing gel.

References

  1. Draelos ZD, DiNardo JC. A re-evaluation of the comedogenicity concept. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2006. PMID 16488305
  2. Mills OH Jr, Kligman AM. A human model for assessing comedogenic substances. Arch Dermatol. 1982. PMID 7138047
  3. Fulton JE Jr et al. Comedogenicity of current therapeutic products, cosmetics, and ingredients in the rabbit ear. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1984. PMID 6229554
  4. Nguyen SH et al. Comedogenicity in rabbit: some cosmetic ingredients/vehicles. Cutan Ocul Toxicol. 2007. PMID 18058303
  5. Waranuch N et al. Safety assessment on comedogenicity of dermatological products containing d-alpha tocopheryl acetate in Asian subjects: A double-blind randomized controlled trial. Contemp Clin Trials Commun. 2021. PMID 34471722
  6. Singh S et al. Acne cosmetica revisited: a case-control study shows a dose-dependent inverse association between overall cosmetic use and post-adolescent acne. Dermatology. 2013. PMID 23859829
  7. American Academy of Dermatology. 10 skin care habits that can worsen acne. https://www.aad.org/public/diseases/acne/skin-care/habits-stop
  8. DermNet. Comedonal acne. https://dermnetnz.org/topics/comedonal-acne

Get started

Talk to us about the product you plan to launch

Please send us your product direction and expected quantities. Our team will get back to you during business hours.

Công ty cổ phần Dược mỹ phẩm Butter-C · Business registration no. 0108681386 (Hanoi Department of Planning and Investment, 03/04/2019)
Head office: Huu Le village, Dai Thanh commune, Hanoi · Factory: Thanh Oai Industrial Cluster, Binh Minh commune, Hanoi, Vietnam
Hotline 0967 176 511 · [email protected] · privacy policy
Product catalog →